• Skip to main content
  • Skip to footer

Josh Hillis

Eating skills, psychology, and workouts

  • About Josh
  • Values
  • Coaching
  • Book
  • Podcasts
  • Blog
You are here: Home / #StrengthMatters / Carbohydrate Cycling and Other Advanced Diet Confusion

josh20150602 / June 24, 2014

Carbohydrate Cycling and Other Advanced Diet Confusion

So I have a few clients who are carbohydrate cycling right now, all of them have been solidly keeping a food journal, tracking, and planning their meals for at least four months.

But sometimes when we introduce carbohydrate cycling, it becomes this big overwhelming thing.  Getting the protein and carbs right on different days.  So I always like to put it in perspective:

First Priority: Calories

Second Priority: Getting enough Protein

Third Priority: The Quality of Carbohydrates and Fats

Fourth Priority: Advanced Timing (Carbohydrate cycling, Intermittent Fasting, Meal Timing, and so on) *Least Important!*
Scratch that, it’s not even “least important,” it’s likely setting you back. For many, it does more harm than good.

So it’s important to note that while those things can help, they are also the least important part of the equation. If you don’t have the calories right, you aren’t going to lose any fat at all, regardless of your protein, your food quality, or especially, the absolute least important part of the puzzle – your advanced timing strategy.  It will make no difference.

And then, the next thing you should handle is protein.  Thtat way you’ll feel more full, and you’ll hold on to muscle while you’re losing fat.

And – only if you already have calories and protein handled – then can you move on to quality of carbohydrates and fats.  With whole food, better quality carbohydrates and fats, you’ll feel more full and usually get more volume of food for less calories.

Lastly – and only if all of the above is perfect – then you can get a boost from an advanced timing strategy.  I can’t emphasize enough that it will make no difference (regardless of the marketing bullshit you’ve been told) without getting everything else in line first.

There very truly is a hierarchy of what is going to make the most difference in your diet.  Don’t be fooled when people try to sell you a second, third, or fourth priority only plan.

UPDATE: There was a time when I went through a phase where I thought carbohydrate cycling might be a high level, useful tool. It’s not. It’s really not. If you’re a pro-bodybuilder or a fitness model and you like it, that’s cool. For the average person, it hurts much more than it helps.

What I’ve found to be more effective, is having clients get a solid, balanced meal in, about every 4-6 hours. There’s no magic to that, it just works really well for self-regulating eating, like, it makes it easier to eat when hungry and stop when full. If you really want to try fasting, try out fasting between meals.

Reader Interactions

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Footer

Program and Coaching

JH Eating Skills Program and Coaching Group

Develop the skills of eating autonomy; Put yourself in the driver's seat with food.

Links

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • LinkedIn
  • YouTube

a seven minute lesson on motivation

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=x-DBZgpdu5M

Search Form

© 2025 Josh Hillis

  • Home
  • About Josh
  • Values
  • Podcasts
  • Coaching
  • Blog
  • Privacy Policy